Yeah, Natalie had really started to affect her dad’s way of thinking.Instead of protecting Laura, her dad had started to protect Natalie in every argument.She had always felt really uncomfortable around him, so in school, she’d just avoid him. She came to him with her story, nearly too embarrassed to tell him about the way Alex looked at her.
aka I'm a slut for bad girl Carmilla, for fake relationships and for high school AUs. Natalie had shown interest in Laura from the moment they met, asking her about school and playing pranks on Laura’s dad with her.
The pair's first encounter with the strange quality of the situation they're entering is when a strange object flies at their car's windshield while they're driving down a heavily wooded road.
At their destination, Chris begins noticing the weird interactions with Rose's parents — played by Keener and Whitford — and the distant, Stepford-like existence of the black people employed by the older couple.
Slowly, Laura could see the hate in Natalie’s eyes increasing and she could hear from Natalie’s voice that she was starting to despise Laura.
Apparently she was the only one whom it was clear to though, because when she talked to her dad about it, he told her that she was being ridiculous and that Natalie loved her.
So what better way to piss him and Laura's new evil stepmom off than by dating the school's bad girl? Her Nissan was only one of many things she had to share since her dad met Natalie. Besides the fact that she had liked anyone who could make her dad happy – God knows he deserved to be, after mourning her mother for eight years – she actually liked his date, with her blonde hair and kind, blue eyes.